Re: ddg.mono to make a melodic midi phrase containing polyphony into monophonic midi


Forums > MaxMSP > ddg.mono to make a melodic midi phrase containing polyphony into monophonic midi
May 28, 2012 | 2:46 am

I just did some testing with this, and even changed the code to force a note-off at every note-on (a requirement for dealing with an intrinsically polyphonic synthesizer). Even with some code changes, we run into a difficult issue: the serial nature of MIDI notes.

For example, if we hit a chord stack on a keyboard containing C, E, G, D, the notes aren’t sent to the notein object as a chord stack; it is sent to notein as four individual notes in some arbitrary order. Let’s assume that the order is as shown (C, E, G, D). ddg.mono sees each note come in, stores it and sounds it in that order (if Last Note priority is chosen). When you release the notes, the note-off messages are also sent serially (in some arbitrary order), and may also sound because previous notes are being released from the storage stack, and a new note is becoming the ‘current’ note.

In doing some basic testing with Live, it appears that chord stacks are sent in low-to-high note order. Thus, even with changes to the code to support polyphonic synthesizer input, you get faux polyphony as the individual notes are all received, sounded, stored, then potentially re-sounded on key release.

Eliminating this problem would either require some sort of speedlim-like behavior, or receipt-time encoding/decoding – both of which are too fragile to consider at this time. If someone were to have a good theoretical alternative, I’d be willing to try to code it up.

[ddg]