Baek Santarek

I have a group of objects that I am trying to ungroup. However, 

 crashes every time I click on "Ungroup".

group_debug.maxpat

I have a group of objects that I am trying to ungroup. However, Max 8.0.3 (64 bit) crashes every time I click on "Ungroup".

I would like to give you more details from the crash log but I don't know where to find it. Could you please navigate me so I can post the log?

I attached the patcher which contains the group. Try to ungroup the grouped items and see if it crashes for you.

Hi,
I have a group of objects that I am trying to ungroup. However, Max 8.0.3 (64 bit) crashes every time I click on "Ungroup".
I would like

max-8-crashes-every-time-when-trying-to-ungroup-objects

OK, I have found how to reproduce this problem:

Then double-click on one of the objects in order to select it  exclusively  from the group without actually ungrouping them.

Use alt drag to duplicate the selected object.

The group gets messed up. If you try to ungroup the group Max will crash.

In order to get the group somewhat working again rename one of the objects to 'loadbangx' and press Enter.

Doing so will ungroup the original instance of the duplicated object and fixes the group.

Hello forum admin I'm facing same problem please help me!!!

I unfortunately can't reproduce the crash without following your steps. The group gets messed up, thought, but here they ungroup without crashing. I do experience a lot of crashes with grouped objects as well, that't why I not using this feature. I contacted support already after the release of Max 8.0.0 and sent over some macOs crash reports; but as these crashes are not predictable they weren't able to reproduce the issue, hence no progress.... :(

I am very interested in following up on this issue. Please post any new insight you may have. I'll do the same. It's a pity not to be able to use grouping!

I unfortunately can't reproduce the crash without  following your steps. The group gets messed up, thought, but here they ungroup without crashing.  I do experience a lot of crashes with grouped objects as well, that't why I not using this feature. I contacted support already after the release of Max 8.0.0 and sent over some macOs crash reports; but as these crashes are not predictable they weren't able to reproduce the issue, hence no progress.... :( 

I am very interested in following  up on this issue. Please post any new insight you may have. I'll do the same. It's a pity not to be able to use grouping!

PS: Here it seems that in general Max is more likely to crash if there ore object groups inside bpatchers that load abstractions.

Max crashes every time when trying to ungroup objects (8.0.3 (64 bit))