Device not usable if patch open in max msp


    Oct 11 2019 | 6:10 pm
    When max msp is opened with the patch of a device, the device is not usuable in Ableton, it's grayed like this :
    So that it becomes usable, I need to close the patch in max msp.
    This means each time I want to test the patch after editing it, I loose my zoom level, the position of the windows, the side bars and so on.
    Is there a way to tell max msp to activate the device in Ableton without closing it?
    Thanks

    • Oct 11 2019 | 8:08 pm
      i think that happens when you recently saved a new version to disk.
    • Oct 11 2019 | 9:04 pm
      Whether I modified the patch or not, until I close the patch, the device is not usable in Ableton.
      Closing the patch means losing the zoom, the size of the window, the side bar content and so on. This drasticaly slows down the development cycle.
    • Oct 11 2019 | 11:52 pm
      i am not sure how it could be releated anyway. but i am vaguely guessing that you could solve it by either crossgrading to max4live - or by always working on a copy, so that you dont open the same document with two different programs.
    • Oct 11 2019 | 11:55 pm
      some of the max-releated consequences could also be fixed using [thispatcher]
    • Oct 14 2019 | 3:41 pm
      I'm already using max4live so i don't understand the solution.
      I'm finding it difficult to believe i'm the only one facing that issue.
      Loosing an IDE window configuration each time you want to test your code is very time consuming
    • Oct 14 2019 | 7:10 pm
      I found a partial solution by opening a non embedded max msp instance that I downloaded on the cycling74 website.
      When I hit "ctrl + s" on this instance, the device is instantly reloaded and usable in ableton.
      The only issue is that parameters are not linked, meaning that when I move a dial in ableton using my Midi controller, the dial does not move in max msp.
      It's a better solution because I'm not loosing all the IDE configuration (zoom level, opened windows, etc..) each time I want to try the device.
      But now I must save before I can use the midi controller.
    • Oct 14 2019 | 11:49 pm
      Not sure, but it sounds like you might be running into the issues discussed in the Max for Live documentation about Preview Mode.
    • Oct 15 2019 | 3:29 am
      Can your hardware actually handle this?
    • Oct 15 2019 | 7:22 am
      Not sure, but it sounds like you might be running into the issues discussed in the Max for Live documentation about Preview Mode.
      Thanks for pointing this I did not know about preview mode. I will test disabling it. But from what I could quickly read it seems the most stable, convenient and deterministic way to develop a device while being able to test it is by having a separate standalone max msp instance opened.
      Can your hardware actually handle this?
      I don't understand the question :)