[help]Can max/msp read message from sudden motion sensor on macbook?
Jan 23 2012 | 9:14 am
Can max/msp read message from sudden motion sensor on macbook?
thx for any reply!
- Jan 23 2012 | 10:04 am
- Jan 23 2012 | 5:41 pmit makes me sad that someone would use a computer in this manner. Especially when there are things like wiimotes.
- Jan 23 2012 | 6:02 pm
- Jan 23 2012 | 8:03 pm
- Jan 23 2012 | 8:49 pm
- Jan 23 2012 | 9:05 pmtep: for the win! dhj: I hear you but... there are just better ways to do this. I am hoping we are engineers here, trying to find optimal solutions.
- Jan 23 2012 | 9:10 pmThe point is that the original poster did not say WHY he wanted the information. So what exactly is it that there are better ways to do?
- Jan 23 2012 | 9:13 pmUm... its a motion sensor. Surely we are trying to sense motion?
- Jan 23 2012 | 9:22 pmIndeed --- but he wants to sense motion of the laptop --- I can think of lots of useful reasons why that might be very handy --- don't see how one can detect motion of a laptop using a wiimote!
- Jan 23 2012 | 9:24 pmExamples? Unless the laptop is an integral onstage part of the performance?
- Jan 23 2012 | 9:25 pm"I am hoping we are engineers here, trying to find optimal solutions" - where the hell did you get that idea?! this is the bloody max forum, not stackoverflow.com! the point is, we are not engineers!
- Jan 23 2012 | 9:31 pmWow, pid, you seemed so levelheaded before...I am aware that there are many creatives here. I admire them alot. I wish I were one of them. I'm not. Im a tech guy. I make stuff work so the creatives can get on with their creativing. Regardless, whether or not we are creatives unless or last name is Kardashian or Hilton we must deal with limited resources. Insofar as resources are limited IMHO it is a good idea to use them as wisely as possible. IMHO moving a notebook around at a high rate of speed is not a wise use of resources.
- Jan 23 2012 | 9:37 pmI am a tech guy too. And that is PRECISELY why I wrote that blog. People who are creative often have something in mind completely different than what others assume.You and I don't know precisely why the original author wants to detect motion of his sensor. Until we know WHY, I believe strongly that it is not our place to tell someone they shouldn't do it!
- Jan 23 2012 | 10:04 pmShouldn't is strong. More like Why would you?I think both you and I have the same goal - to see why this person would want to do this.
- Jan 23 2012 | 10:05 pmbtw - scorcerer = one of the few valid excises I've seen to buy an ipad. Any thought to releasing it on other platforms? I'd love to use it with my kinect-to-midi app.
- Jan 23 2012 | 10:16 pmunless I'm mistaken, the motion sensor on a mac is just an accelerometer (as in the ipad, iphone etc)...not such a dumb thing to utilise.a few example apps here (and a rather interesting link towards the end of the article, on using the SMS as a HID)EDIT :and just remembered this article from CDM
- Jan 23 2012 | 10:17 pmI saw this being used in a pretty cool way. It was one of those laptop orchestras. I can't remember which. They were using chuck so maybe Plork but a group of people sat on some comfortable cushions each with a networked laptop on their laps. They gently titled their laptops to modulate various parameters in realtime. The focus I think was that the computer itself could be a musical instrument not just something you connect a musical instrument/interface to. If you add in things like the fingerpinger and the camera I think they might be right. You might not need anything more than bluetooth, your laptop and a willingness to sound a bit rubbish until something comes of it.
- Jan 23 2012 | 10:24 pmgqizzle: see? an answer. Not bickering. See how awesome that was?
- Jan 24 2012 | 9:35 amoops, seems like my 'humour' is STILL not coming across on the forums. i must remember to just not do that. (i am 90% tech, too; although i wish i wasn't).
- Jan 24 2012 | 1:38 pmYour humor came across fine to me!
- Jan 24 2012 | 1:45 pmwow... I am getting slow....
- Jan 24 2012 | 6:11 pm"there are many creatives here....I wish I were one of them. I'm not. Im a tech guy"I don't believe you mean this as it sounds. The reason most of us are here is because this technology allows the engineer to be more creative, and the artist to be more, erm, engineer-yBrendan (hippy!!)
- Jan 24 2012 | 8:12 pmum... I think I do? I have some basic music theory, but my original training is in sound engineering. I transitioned to electronics once I figured out that that was where my real strength is. I'm always more interested in coming up with new ways to do things than coming up with new things to do. When I come up with a project my first thought is not "what will I do with it", but "who will use it?".(wow that felt funny)
- Jan 24 2012 | 8:19 pmReason I use MAX is that it "compiles" in real-time, so prototyping is exponentially faster than anything involving make>compile>debug. That and the visual paradigm/messages/etc/. If C++ were faster to work with I'd be over there.