Not Working! - Makenote; pgmout; noteout - MIDI Sound Engine

geddy's icon

Hello all,

I am quite new to Max. I don't quite understand the difference yet, but I have M4L with Ableton Suite so I can't use it standalone, but I can through Live (is there any disadvantage with this or is it the same?).

I have managed to play samples with buffer~ etc but when I try to use the computer internal synth to create sounds, nothing happens.

To demonstrate this, when I look at 'pgmout' in the help files and attempt to play the patch, nothing happens. Can someone please help, I don't know how to proceed?

spectro's icon

I think (but don't know for sure) that Live doesn't give users access to the system's built in MIDI synth - which probably explains why you aren't getting the results you might expect. For more details about the differences between Max and M4L, a quick search yielded this: https://docs.cycling74.com/max5/vignettes/core/live_limitations.html and discussion on this board here: https://cycling74.com/forums/question-about-max-for-live-vs-max/
a little dated now but most - if not all - of it probably still holds.

geddy's icon

Okay thank you for the info. From what I now understand, Live does not give Max access to the in-built MIDI synths, it searches for ones within Live on a Midi track.