jit.cellblock doesn't keep addrow/deleterow changes

Adam Kendall's icon

Hi,

Example patch demoing the problem is below.

I'm using jit.cellblock with "Save cell data with patcher" enabled.

When I use the addrow or deleterow commands, they operate correctly but the changes are not saved with the patcher. e.g., if I have a 10 row cellblock and add an 11th with the addrow command, the 11th row appears but is not saved when I close/open the patcher.

Changes to cell data are changed.

Is this a bug? Or is there a different setting or technique to use to save the new/deleted rows with the patch?

Finally, is it a better practice to attach the cellblock to a coll instead of saving info with the patcher?

Thanks.

Adam

Max Patch
Copy patch and select New From Clipboard in Max.

Adam Kendall's icon

I went ahead and adapted my patch to work with a coll. By adding/removing rows from the coll, I get the behavior I expect.

However... Still wondering why adding/deleting rows doesn't "stick' with this patch. Bug? Expected behavior that isn't documented properly?

Thanks.

Adam Kendall's icon

Bumping because I'm hoping to get an answer for future reference. Is my description of addrow/deleterow a bug? Expected behavior?

Thanks.

Adam

Andrew Pask's icon

Hi Adam,

We'll have a look at it and I'll let you know.

-A

Adam Kendall's icon

Thanks, Andrew.