Max6's groove~ with resampling sounds awfull
Just discovered the new resample feature of groove~. I’m not sure I understand what c74 means with This process dramatically reduces aliasing and other undesirable audio artifacts
If you try the following example (which is just the help file but with a slow speed playback), I’m sure you’ll hear what I mean.
-- Pasted Max Patch, click to expand. --Copy all of the following text. Then, in Max, select New From Clipboard.----------begin_max5_patcher---------- 1154.3oc6Yt0aihCEG+4jOEV7ztRoQ9FDx7zLeC12qppLfSh2gfq.SuLil9Y esM3.jPZn411J0GJgZNXN9m+etDxuGOxKR9LuvC7MvsfQi983QirCYFXT8+O xaM643TVg0LuEoxrx0dSptzCrb1ZthmeOOiEkxMl.qu1BYlpP7K6XH7T2v56 VjkxU1oCUOnHwN4xn+8lYdMFJKUNKwsl0L8yzZ+OxErTm8UFqd4Ad05w3pLk 2DfWDKaoG3tM9rJdkHa4847XUkoAF2Cfl4a9vGZNh0GA2Yti+Ldr4vjABnX4 507LkyqT7msODublnfCdTlVpc99PDYvHh1OhfGDQQkQ0aRn8CCTXnA.DpkFH XfEG9mYb7OorW.OITq.47B15GR0NwTv29Kmg5+mGKKyTau4eD7BeQ4EAhrDh fm5a3kEaT3khW5EPWj82WBjgnWClgBnmClslWTvVx2MjqBSbsm.fumXNbO.g zOPPu+7RuYpHrMUI.SMtFHbtESyuTfAd5fI7pxk5bzmHWx3Ooc8cvRT4hE77 WAq3oOrLWJejCCArLkLaJSr.bCBfOwL2jv+GptQvVlQphxvV2U+wQxtTwi7o KYhrWct1ir7M97tWsuVDbjoXk7I2s5PnLWny+wTBYVaSOjLzuev567Bsj2Ms sPisTOrUUepgJ6C4EhkYlcj1mY9ayVQpnPMfFMbkVw1RqjvVOyB1i7j6YJUt HpTwaNqndKodOwP8zRtbgaX23sAdYlPUndoh4zI6ZvZ8Nq4ZANA7VWUX2BtY Fr2qKzSuQgZWYZibKhNF4v2aLA6JL5XkVjjq1u.qis5lSW1io25emWkwVwt6 iyTo4BEKWAXkIB4Ild.gtrc1gzA8gywATspa9bSo24vSp6N9uRXwMg54Rkzr guwGMYRWHR4dCLJlPda.jJiqDbtUYjLOgmaGY5L+NCFKSk4tvbeHZdfoMfdN C0J9KZYqaqpGk1GFPrcEQoT2wyYAJcZmW0NN5TqBQOa0rqSDdXtfwVh3GbRE e1CWpJVuUgaL36MM.9dHFoGhsmxKjilXS54rAntpqgSvmDFMfSWTQ2XiyM0O sJT5FHW+EIR3VBDrI8+A+99KXwcRBYdPchCIz4P7jdNocv0d1jzPRpARpH9m 6syf9Rp91acMYPf6O8gqKA314A1MeAb5rvPLw2bFcFzOLbqLG82IBV2FvbZ. EoSHQzMi3aeEDTe+vYXSzi9hgyHalkMRezTeuinU65NWr65smScnS2UtcOxc nyJmE+ykVUxv9td0M8PQMKJhaQ8kD9.RX7mBMLAVkip98mM.w6GboKVmt0ET Rg38FT9k98.Mb7oP9RQAa1swg3AqhIevUwTDtYcU8dk9REeLYg8+jHiaRZgI jA2IA9SjLt90.dHYr8gXeu3a8abYmdy3c01Exx7X2Zq9GiBz3pI7BkHayql5 1luMUKiVIRR3YsUAIhBiD2t9f8FjMT2w7RnOr+3e07G6iBc.+oqMWb2AN.24 5Pmg.GyK73JQmg.GB4pQmvOXRY5kzezYk9y3+CD+cO0. -----------end_max5_patcher-----------
Your patch makes the same problem on my Mac (Max 6.0.1, OS 10.7.2).
Same here with max 6.01 and OSX 10.5.8.
Thanks for pointing this out. There are some known issues with groove~ @resample 1 at this point that we are working on, and this is one of them.
6.1.2 didn’t solve the problem…
I also came across the problem a while back that when using an instance of [groove~] with @resampling 1. It turned out that turning on/off playback for the object seemed to very briefly turn the DAC off and then on again.
I’ve since abandoned using it.
6.1.6 didn’t solve the problem…
Same here. Can’t use resampling option with groove due to it sounding like bollucks at slow speeds. It’s been 3 years or so now… Any word from above re this issue?
(sidenote: always thought the comments in the helpfile were humorous: "without resampling :(… with resampling :)"
…not that it was intentionally written because of this issue, just cuz of the way it tries to sell the sound quality :D …I just mean to say, with or without this problem, I like the humorous touch)
Ran across the same issue today with 6.1.9…
Not nice that the problem still exists!
Forums > MaxMSP