Tarik

Perhaps this has been discussed recently - I find searching through the forum a bit difficult sometimes - but anyways, see topic title: How do I prevent Max from forgetting my Midi setup?

On Windows, dealing with MIDI is a headache cause no two applications can use a midi device simultaneously. Meaning in my case the I need to tell Max explicitly NOT to address any of my midi devices. In "Midi Setup" under "Options", I uncheck all of them, but on subsequent start-ups some (but not all!) of the checkmarks sneak back in.

If somehow this isn't directly solvable, alternatively I'd like to know if there's a way that I can have a patch itself deactivate any such midi activations on startup?

Hi,
Perhaps this has been discussed recently - I find searching through the forum a bit difficult sometimes - but anyways, see topic title: 

how-do-i-save-midi-setup-or-how-do-i-set-it-up-inside-a-patch

So - no way to have max remember settings for midi devices?

nope, a patch can not change settings in the operating system.

but... why is it a problem that ports are available which wouldnt work when selected?


nope, a patch can not change settings in the operating system.

The problem is that the ports are being hogged by Max, making them unavailable for other software that I want to run simultaneously. To put it practically:

I plug in my Nanokontrol, Max enables this device both as input and as output. I manually disable this, because I want the Nanokontrol to communicate with Ableton.

Next time I start max, it might or might not have remembered my disabling of Nanokontrol. But I'll notice soon enough when I see that Ableton isn't responding to my slider movements.

I believe that if I make sure that I ALWAYS religiously adhere to a strict order of starting softwares and plugging in devices, I might get some consistency here. But... it significantly speeds up my development time if I'm able to be flexible with plugging and unplugging stuff, quitting and restarting programs, etc

The problem is that the ports are being hogged by Max, making them unavailable for other software that I want to run simultaneously. To put it practically:
I plug in my Nanokontrol, Max enables this device both as input and as output. I manually disable this, because I want the Nanokontrol to communicate with Ableton.
Next time I start max, it might or might not have remembered my disabling of Nanokontrol. But I'll notice soon enough when I see that Ableton isn't responding to my slider movements.

I believe that if I make sure that I ALWAYS religiously adhere to a strict order of starting softwares and plugging in devices, I might get some consistency here. But... it significantly speeds up my development time if I'm able to be flexible with plugging and unplugging stuff, quitting and restarting programs, etc


yes you dont want to be forced to start programs in a certain order, that must be fixed.

i just remembered that we had it somewhere: 

https://cycling74.com/forums/disable-specific-midi-inputsoutputs-when-launching-a-patcher


oh, i see, of course.

yes you dont want to be forced to start programs in a certain order, that must be fixed.

i just remembered that we had it somewhere: https://cycling74.com/forums/disable-specific-midi-inputsoutputs-when-launching-a-patcher


Wah! That's the holy grail I've been searching for... thanks, this really makes my life a lot easier.

...and just in case any future beings run into this post and want to know how I implemented this: 

;max midi portenable "KOMPLETE KONTROL M32 MIDI" 0 0 

where the first 0 is for disable/enable, the second 0 is for input/output.

And they're being triggered by a loadbang and by a 

...which sends out a new list every time a device is added or removed.

...and just in case any future beings run into this post and want to know how I implemented this: 

  I now have a bunch of messages like 
;max midi portenable "KOMPLETE KONTROL M32 MIDI" 0 0 
where the first 0 is for disable/enable, the second 0 is for input/output.
  And they're being triggered by a loadbang and by a 
midiinfo @autopollcontrollers 1 
...which sends out a new list every time a device is added or removed.


How do I save MIDI setup (or how do I set it up inside a patch)?